You added a 3% "kitchen appreciation" fee to cover health insurance for your line cooks. It kept the doors open. Then a regular left a one-star review calling it a scam, a guest refused to pay it, and your bookkeeper forwarded you an article about a new law in another state. Now you are staring at your menu wondering whether the thing keeping you solvent is also about to get you fined.
Here is the short version. No state and no federal rule bans a mandatory service charge. Every new law on the books does the same thing: it tells you how to disclose the fee, not whether you can keep it. Get the disclosure wrong and you are exposed; get it right and the fee is yours. This guide walks through the federal picture and the four states leading the 2026 wave, in plain English, so you can check your own menu before someone else does.
This is a practical compliance explainer, not legal advice. For a specific fee in your state, confirm with your attorney or your state attorney general's office.
Key takeaways
- No US jurisdiction bans mandatory service charges. The federal rule and all four state laws covered here are disclosure rules - they govern how you show the fee, not whether you may charge it.
- The FTC's "junk fee" rule does not reach restaurants. It covers only live-event tickets and short-term lodging (FTC, 2025). The action for restaurants has moved to the states.
- California (since July 1, 2024) requires the fee to be shown with an explanation of its purpose on any menu or display that lists prices (JD Supra, 2024).
- Minnesota (since January 1, 2025) wants the percentage of any automatic and mandatory gratuity disclosed clearly and conspicuously (Minnesota Statutes, 2025).
- Florida (July 1, 2026) and Colorado (January 1, 2026) are the two newest. Colorado is the only one that makes you disclose where the money goes (Colorado General Assembly, 2025).
- Service fees are not credit-card surcharges. Different rules, different states - don't mix them up (see the credit-card surcharge rules by state).
Are restaurant service charges legal in the US?
Yes. As of 2026, there is no state in the country, and no federal rule, that prohibits a restaurant from adding a mandatory service charge, operations charge, or automatic gratuity. Service fees have moved from a coastal experiment to a mainstream tool: about 3.7% of restaurant transactions carried a service fee in Q2 2024, more than doubling since the beginning of 2022 (Square, 2024), according to Square's own transaction data.
What is regulated - and increasingly so - is disclosure. A cluster of states now say that if you charge a mandatory fee, you have to tell the customer about it in a specific way, in a specific place, before they are surprised by it on the check. The fee stays legal. The ambush does not.
That single idea is the through-line for everything below: the law does not care that you charge a fee. It cares that you hid it. If a reasonable guest can see the fee and understand what it is before they order, you are almost always on the right side of these laws.
Does the FTC "junk fee" rule ban restaurant service fees?
No - and for most restaurants it does not apply at all. The Federal Trade Commission's Rule on Unfair or Deceptive Fees (16 CFR Part 464) took effect on May 12, 2025 and "prohibits bait-and-switch pricing" (FTC, 2025). But its scope is narrow. The FTC is explicit that "businesses selling live-event tickets and short-term lodging are covered" (FTC, 2025) - concert tickets and hotels, not restaurants.
Even inside its scope, the rule is a transparency rule, not a ban. It requires covered businesses to show the all-in total price up front and to describe fees honestly rather than hiding behind vague labels. It does not outlaw charging a fee.
So the practical answer for an independent operator: the federal "junk fee" rule is not your problem. The reason you keep hearing about it is that it kicked off a national conversation about surprise fees, and state lawmakers picked up the baton. The real compliance work is now at the state level, and it varies a lot depending on where your dining room sits.
US restaurant service-fee disclosure laws at a glance
Here is how the federal rule and the four leading states compare. Every one of them regulates disclosure; none bans the fee.
| Rule | In effect | Bans the fee? | What you must disclose | Who enforces |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FTC Unfair or Deceptive Fees Rule (16 CFR Part 464) | May 12, 2025 | No - and it does not cover restaurants (only live-event tickets + short-term lodging) | All-in total price + honest fee labels, where it applies | FTC |
| California (SB 478 + SB 1524) | Jul 1, 2024; restaurant disclosure Jul 1, 2025 | No | The mandatory fee shown with an explanation of its purpose on any menu, ad, or display that shows the price | Consumer Legal Remedies Act |
| Minnesota (Minn. Stat. 325D.44) | Jan 1, 2025 | No | A clear, conspicuous disclosure of the percentage of any automatic and mandatory gratuity in the displayed price | State deceptive-trade-practice law |
| Florida (SB 606) | Jul 1, 2026 | No | The "operations charge" on menus, apps, and signage, plus its own line on the receipt (gratuity and tax on separate lines) | State law; no private lawsuits |
| Colorado (HB25-1090) | Jan 1, 2026 | No | The amount of the mandatory service charge and how it is distributed, in the total price | Colorado Consumer Protection Act |
The rest of this guide takes each state in turn, because the wording of "disclosure" is doing a lot of work and the details are where owners trip.
How California's rules work (SB 478 and SB 1524)
California wrote the template the other states are now copying, then carved out a path for restaurants. SB 478, the state's "hidden fee" law, amended the Consumer Legal Remedies Act and "is now fully enforceable as of July 1, 2024" (JD Supra, 2024). On its own, SB 478 pushes toward all-in pricing - mandatory fees folded into the displayed price.
That alarmed restaurants, so the legislature passed SB 1524. It does not exempt restaurants outright. Instead it lets food-service businesses keep a mandatory fee or charge, as long as they "clearly and conspicuously display a mandatory fee or charge with an explanation of its purpose, on any advertisement, menu, or other display that contains the price" (JD Supra, 2024). That restaurant disclosure requirement took effect July 1, 2025.
The operative words are with an explanation of its purpose. A line that just says "4% service fee" is weaker than "4% service fee, which funds staff healthcare." If you operate in California, the fix is usually a one-line note on every menu and ordering screen that both states the fee and says what it pays for.

What Minnesota requires
Minnesota took a gratuity-focused angle. Under Minn. Stat. 325D.44, it is a deceptive trade practice to advertise or display a price that "does not include all mandatory fees or surcharges" (Minnesota Statutes, 2025), and the law has been in force since January 1, 2025 (Minnesota Session Laws, 2024).
Food and beverage establishments get a specific compliance path. The statute says such a business complies if its displayed price "includes a clear and conspicuous disclosure of the percentage of any automatic and mandatory gratuities charged" (Minnesota Statutes, 2025). Note two things. First, this path is written around automatic and mandatory gratuities specifically - the percentage you add as a built-in tip - not every conceivable fee. Second, there is no blanket "restaurants are exempt" clause; the only general exemptions in the statute are for certain motor-vehicle, utility, and real-estate-settlement charges. If you run an auto-gratuity in Minnesota, state the percentage up front, clearly, where the price is shown.
Florida's new "operations charge" law (SB 606)
Florida's SB 606 is the most prescriptive of the group, and it went into effect July 1, 2026 (Jackson Lewis, 2025). It amends Section 509.214 of the Florida Statutes and governs any mandatory "operations charge" - the law's umbrella term that sweeps in service charges, gratuity charges, and similar non-tax add-ons.
The law tells you where the notice has to appear. A notice of the operations charge, with its amount or percentage, must be on menus, menu boards, contracts, and ordering apps or websites; where no menu is provided, it has to be obvious on a sign by the register; and it must appear on the bill (Jackson Lewis, 2025). The receipt rule is the one that catches POS setups off guard: "operations charges must appear on customer receipts and must be on their own lines. Gratuities and sales tax must appear on separate lines" (Jackson Lewis, 2025).

One relief for owners: the law "does not create a private cause of action related to compliance" (Jackson Lewis, 2025), so a disgruntled customer cannot personally sue you over it. If you run in Florida, the practical task is a menu reprint plus a POS check: make sure the charge, the gratuity, and the tax each print on their own receipt line.
Colorado: disclose the amount and where it goes (HB25-1090)
Colorado's HB25-1090, "Protections Against Deceptive Pricing Practices," has been in effect since January 1, 2026 (Colorado General Assembly, 2025). Like the others, it is built on total-price disclosure. What makes it different is one phrase.
A food and beverage service establishment complies if it "includes a disclosure in the total price for a good or service the amount of any mandatory service charge and how the mandatory service charge is distributed" (Colorado General Assembly, 2025). Colorado is the only state in this group that makes you disclose where the charge goes - whether it is kept by the house, pooled for staff, or earmarked for something specific. A violation is treated as a deceptive practice under the Colorado Consumer Protection Act.
If you charge a mandatory service fee in Colorado, "3% service charge" is not enough on its own. You need the amount and a short statement of how it is distributed - for example, "3% service charge distributed to kitchen and front-of-house staff."
How to run a service fee without getting burned
Across all five regimes the compliance pattern rhymes. A short checklist that keeps you clean almost everywhere:
- Name the fee and its purpose. "Service charge" is vague. "4% kitchen operations charge" with a one-line explanation of what it funds satisfies the strictest states and heads off the one-star reviews.
- Show it before the order, not after. Put the fee on the physical menu, the menu board, and every online ordering screen - the same places a guest sees prices. A surprise on the check is exactly what these laws target.
- Give it its own receipt line. Keep the service/operations charge, any gratuity, and sales tax on separate lines. Florida requires it; it is good practice everywhere and makes disputes easy to settle.
- Say where it goes if you are in Colorado - and consider doing it anyway. Transparency about distribution is becoming the norm and is the single most effective answer to "is this just extra profit for the owner?"
- Keep it consistent online. The fee needs to read the same on your own website and ordering page as it does on the printed menu. That is easiest when you control the page yourself - the kind of thing an AI website builder like DineHere handles in minutes, so the disclosed fee and its explanation sit on your own ordering screen rather than buried in a third-party POS prompt.
The deeper point: a mandatory service fee is one of the few levers you control directly against rising food and labor costs, and it does not hand a slice to an aggregator the way a delivery-app commission does. Disclosed properly, it is yours to keep. The only way to lose it is to hide it.
Frequently asked questions
Are mandatory service charges legal at US restaurants in 2026?
Yes. No state and no federal rule bans a mandatory service charge. The federal "junk fee" rule and the state laws in California, Minnesota, Florida, and Colorado all regulate how you disclose the fee, not whether you can charge it.
Does the FTC junk fee rule apply to restaurants?
No. The FTC's Rule on Unfair or Deceptive Fees (16 CFR Part 464) covers only live-event tickets and short-term lodging (FTC, 2025). Restaurants are outside its scope. The state laws are what you need to watch.
What is the difference between a service charge and a credit-card surcharge?
A service charge is a mandatory fee you add to the bill, often to fund wages, benefits, or operations. A credit-card surcharge is a fee that offsets the cost of accepting a card, and it is governed by a completely different set of state laws and card-network caps. See the credit-card surcharge rules by state for that side.
Do I have to put the service fee on my menu?
In the states regulating this, effectively yes. California requires the fee to appear on any menu or display that shows prices, and Florida requires notice on menus, apps, and signage. Even where it is not explicitly required, showing the fee before the guest orders is the safest practice.
How do I disclose a service charge in California?
Show the fee "with an explanation of its purpose" on any advertisement, menu, or display that contains the price (JD Supra, 2024). A line that both states the fee and says what it funds meets the requirement, which took effect July 1, 2025.
What does Minnesota require for automatic gratuities?
Minnesota's law (in effect since January 1, 2025) says a food or beverage establishment complies by clearly and conspicuously disclosing the percentage of any automatic and mandatory gratuity in the displayed price (Minnesota Statutes, 2025).
When does Florida's SB 606 take effect and what does it require?
SB 606 took effect July 1, 2026. It requires the operations charge to be disclosed on menus, apps, and register signage, and to appear on its own line on the receipt, with gratuity and sales tax on separate lines (Jackson Lewis, 2025).
What makes Colorado's law different?
Colorado's HB25-1090 (in effect January 1, 2026) is the only one in this group that requires you to disclose both the amount of the mandatory service charge and how it is distributed (Colorado General Assembly, 2025).
Can a customer sue me over a service fee?
It depends on the state. Florida's SB 606 does not create a private cause of action, so customers cannot personally sue over compliance with it (Jackson Lewis, 2025). Other states enforce through consumer-protection statutes. Confirm your own state's exposure with an attorney.
Should I keep my service fee or fold it into menu prices?
Both are legal; it is a business call. A disclosed, well-explained fee is transparent about rising costs and easy to remove if the market turns. Folding it into prices is simpler but harder to reverse. Whatever you choose, disclose it clearly and keep the wording identical across your menu, receipts, and online ordering.


