
Ask a US restaurant owner what they want from a point-of-sale system and the honest answer is rarely "more features." It is "stop charging me for things I didn't agree to." The monthly software fee on the brochure is the small part. The processing rate on every dollar you ring up, the hardware bill, and the multi-year contract are where the real money goes — and where owners get caught.
That worry stopped being abstract on October 29, 2026, when the Federal Trade Commission, seven state attorneys general, and California sued Toast Inc. over alleged hidden and unauthorized fees (FTC, 2026). Toast denies the allegations and is fighting the case in court. Nothing is proven. But the suit put the question every owner should already be asking right at the front: what will this register actually cost me, and how hard is it to leave? This guide compares the three systems most independents weigh — Toast, Square, and Clover — on exactly that.
Key takeaways
- Judge a POS on its all-in cost, not the sticker price. A "$0 per month" plan can cost more than a paid one once you add the processing rate on every sale. The software fee is rarely where the money is.
- Square is the only one of the three with no long-term contract. Its Free plan is a genuine $0 and it charges no termination fees (NerdWallet, 2026) — the low-risk way to test a system.
- Toast and Clover both lock you in for years. NerdWallet reports Toast contracts run two to three years (NerdWallet, 2026); Clover restaurant deals typically run 36 to 48 months (Tech.co, 2026).
- The FTC's October 2026 complaint alleges Toast buried fees — including an undisclosed early-termination fee of $150 for every remaining month of the contract (FTC, 2026). Toast strongly disagrees and says the case changes nothing about its pricing or support.
- No system "owns" the market. In the small-restaurant space, Clover holds an estimated 20% share, Toast 17%, and Square 13% (Payments Dive, 2026, citing Baird), so "best" depends on your size, service model, and how you take payments.
Which POS should you choose?
For most independent US restaurants, Square for Restaurants is the safest place to start: a real free plan and no contract, so you can trial it without risk. Toast is the most complete all-in-one for busy full-service spots that want everything on one system — but it carries the longest lock-in and is the subject of the FTC action, so read every line before you sign. Clover gives you the most hardware flexibility and competitive card-present rates, but it is sold through banks and resellers on multi-year terms, so the deal you are quoted can vary a lot.
"Best" is really the wrong question. The right one is: what will this cost me each month, including the processing line, and how long am I tied in? Two systems with the same monthly fee can be hundreds of dollars apart once a month of card sales runs through them. The numbers below let you compare on that basis.
Toast vs Square vs Clover: 2026 price comparison
| Toast | Square for Restaurants | Clover | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Software / month | $0 Starter Kit / $69+ Point of Sale | $0 Free / $49 Plus / $149 Premium | $130–$354 (restaurant plans) |
| In-person card rate | 2.49% + 15¢ (hardware paid upfront); 3.09–3.69% + 15¢ pay-as-you-go | 2.6% + 15¢ (Free); 2.5% (Plus); 2.4% (Premium) | 2.3% + 10¢ (card-present) |
| Contract | Two to three years | No long-term contract; no termination fees | Typically 36–48 months |
| Processor | Toast only | Square only | Fiserv only (no third-party processors) |
| Best for | All-in-one depth, full-service | Low-commitment value, start free | Hardware choice, competitive rates |
Software prices and processing rates verified November 2026 from the publishers cited in each section below. Rates change often, pay-as-you-go rates are quoted as ranges, and some deals are negotiated — always confirm the current figure and your exact plan in writing before you sign.
Why the processing line, not the sticker price, decides your bill

The software fee is the number vendors advertise. The processing rate is the number that actually empties the account, because it applies to every dollar of card sales, month after month.
Run the math. Say you take $40,000 a month in card sales — modest for a small full-service spot. A difference of just half a percentage point in your processing rate is $200 a month, or $2,400 a year — more than most owners pay for their entire POS software. That is why a "$0 software" plan on a high processing rate can cost you more than a paid plan on a low one. The headline fee is a rounding error next to the rate.
This is the same trap owners already know from delivery-app commissions — the percentage you barely notice on each order adds up to the biggest line on the statement. Always compare POS systems on the rate, then the hardware, then the software, in that order.
What the FTC's October 2026 complaint says about Toast's fees
The clearest reason to read a POS contract closely right now is the government's own case. On October 29, 2026, the FTC — joined by the attorneys general of Colorado, Florida, Illinois, Iowa, Nebraska, Oklahoma, and Utah, plus California through the Los Angeles County Counsel and San Francisco City Attorney — filed suit against Toast in the Northern District of California (FTC, 2026).
These are allegations only. No court has ruled, and Toast denies them. The company says it is "prepared to defend our business and fight this unprecedented action through litigation" and that "nothing about today's news changes our customer service, pricing, or support" (Nation's Restaurant News, 2026). Read what follows as a checklist of clauses to look for in any POS contract, not as proven fact.
According to the FTC's complaint, Toast:
- Advertises a "Pay-as-you-Go" plan with $0 hardware and software per month but "imposes various types of fees… which Toast fails to clearly disclose."
- Charges an undisclosed early-termination fee of $150 per month for each remaining month of the contract. The complaint cites one owner billed $5,318.87 to cancel, which Toast refused to refund.
- Bills restaurants that temporarily close $85 a month to keep payment processing active.
- Requires customers who do not start processing within 120 days to return all hardware or pay its full retail value.
- Enrolls customers in add-on services — such as timekeeping and payroll — and charges for them "without their consent."
- Uses a "counterintuitive, multi-step cancellation process" needing 30 days' written notice of an "intent not to renew" that "is not clearly disclosed."
- Added a 99-cent fee to certain online orders over $10 from September 2021 through late July 2023 that "went to Toast and not the restaurants."
(FTC, 2026.) Whatever the court decides, the lesson for an owner is simple: every one of those is a clause type you can look for and negotiate before you sign — with Toast or anyone else.
Toast: best for all-in-one depth, if you read the contract
Toast is built for full-service restaurants that want one system running the floor, the kitchen, online ordering, and payroll. Software starts at $0 for the Starter Kit and $69 and up for the Point of Sale plan (NerdWallet, 2026). In-person processing is 2.49% plus 15 cents if you buy hardware upfront, or 3.09% to 3.69% plus 15 cents on the pay-as-you-go option (NerdWallet, 2026).
The depth is real, and for a high-volume full-service operation the single-system simplicity can be worth it. The trade-offs are the lock-in and the processor: NerdWallet reports Toast "locks you into a contract for two to three years," and Toast runs its own payment processing, so you cannot shop the rate separately (NerdWallet, 2026). Given the FTC action, read the early-termination and auto-renewal clauses line by line before committing.
Square: best for no-contract, start-free simplicity
Square is the easiest system to try because trying it costs nothing. Plans run $0 for Free, $49 for Plus, and $149 for Premium (NerdWallet, 2026). In-person cards process at 2.6% plus 15 cents on the Free plan, dropping to 2.5% on Plus and 2.4% on Premium (NerdWallet, 2026).
The headline advantage in a year defined by the Toast suit is the terms: Square has "no long-term contracts or termination fees" and lets you "upgrade, downgrade or cancel at any time without penalty" (NerdWallet, 2026). For a first-time buyer, a counter-service spot, or any owner burned by a multi-year deal, that is the whole appeal. The limit is depth: very busy full-service restaurants may outgrow Square's table-service tools and want the paid tiers. But as a low-risk way off a clunky legacy register, it is hard to beat.
Clover: flexible hardware, but check who's selling it to you
Clover, owned by Fiserv, offers the widest hardware range — Station, Mini, and Flex units — and competitive card-present pricing. Restaurant plans run from about $130 to $354 a month, with the Full-Service Standard plan at $239 (Tech.co, 2026). Card-present processing on restaurant plans is 2.3% plus 10 cents — the lowest in-person rate of the three on paper (Tech.co, 2026).
The catch is how Clover is sold. It is distributed through banks and merchant-services resellers, so the plan price and rate you are quoted can differ from Clover's direct pricing — read your own agreement, not a review. Two more traps: you "can't use third-party processors with Clover," so you are tied to Fiserv, and contracts "typically last around 36 or 48 months" with an early-termination fee "equal to the remaining balance you owe," which Tech.co notes "has been over $500" for some users (Tech.co, 2026). Great hardware, but the lock-in is as real as Toast's.
The lock-in traps to read for before you sign

Whichever system you lean toward, the contract — not the demo — is where you win or lose. Before signing anything, check:
- Contract length and auto-renewal. Is it month-to-month or a multi-year term, and does it renew automatically? Square is no-contract; Toast and Clover tie you in for years.
- The early-termination fee. How is it calculated? Both Toast (per the FTC complaint, allegedly $150 per remaining month) and Clover (your remaining balance) can run to thousands of dollars.
- Who does the processing. If the POS only works with its own processor, you can never shop the rate. All three tie payments to one processor.
- What happens if you close or pause. The FTC alleges Toast charges $85 a month even when a restaurant temporarily shuts. Ask what you owe during a slow season or a renovation.
- Add-ons and "bundles." Confirm in writing exactly which services you are enrolled in and what each one costs, so nothing appears on the statement you never agreed to.
Get every rate, fee, and term in writing before you commit. A verbal "we'll take care of you" is not a contract.
How to choose: a 6-point checklist
- Add up the all-in monthly cost — software plus your real card volume at the quoted processing rate — not the sticker price.
- Match the depth to your service model. Full-service with heavy kitchen and online ordering leans Toast; simple counter or café service leans Square; hardware-specific needs lean Clover.
- Decide how much lock-in you can stomach. If you want the freedom to leave, only Square offers no contract today.
- Read the early-termination and auto-renewal clauses before anything else, and price the cost of walking away.
- Get the processing rate in writing, including online and keyed-in rates, and whether it can change mid-contract.
- Keep your own front door off the POS. Your website and direct-ordering page should live somewhere you control, so switching POS never takes your online presence or customers with it. Tools like DineHere build an independent restaurant a site in minutes, separate from whichever processor you choose.
Compare any shortlist against our wider roundup of the best POS systems for US restaurants, and once you've picked, make sure you understand your credit-card surcharge rules by state so you know what you can and can't pass on.
Frequently asked questions
Is Toast still worth it after the FTC lawsuit?
Toast remains a capable all-in-one POS, and the October 2026 FTC case is unproven — Toast denies the allegations and continues to operate normally (Nation's Restaurant News, 2026). The practical takeaway is not "avoid Toast" but "read the contract" — especially the early-termination, auto-renewal, and add-on clauses the FTC complaint describes (FTC, 2026).
Which is cheapest: Toast, Square, or Clover?
It depends on your card volume, not the monthly fee. Square's Free plan is a genuine $0 software (NerdWallet, 2026), and Clover has the lowest in-person rate at 2.3% plus 10 cents (Tech.co, 2026). Add your real monthly card sales at each quoted rate to see which is actually cheapest for you.
Does Square really have no contract?
Yes. NerdWallet reports Square has "no long-term contracts or termination fees" and lets you cancel at any time without penalty (NerdWallet, 2026). That is its main advantage over both Toast and Clover, which tie you in for years.
How long is a Toast contract?
NerdWallet reports Toast "locks you into a contract for two to three years" (NerdWallet, 2026). The FTC complaint also alleges an undisclosed early-termination fee of $150 for every remaining month (FTC, 2026), so confirm the exact term and exit cost before signing.
How long is a Clover contract?
Clover restaurant deals "typically last around 36 or 48 months," with an early-termination fee equal to your remaining balance (Tech.co, 2026). Because Clover is sold through banks and resellers, confirm the term in your own agreement rather than relying on a general figure.
Can I use my own card processor with these systems?
No. Toast processes payments through Toast, Square through Square, and Clover only works with Fiserv — you "can't use third-party processors with Clover" (Tech.co, 2026). With all three, you cannot shop the processing rate separately, so negotiate it as part of the deal.
What processing rate should a small restaurant expect?
In-person card-present rates on these systems run roughly 2.3% to 2.6% plus 10 to 15 cents on standard plans (NerdWallet, 2026; Tech.co, 2026). Toast's pay-as-you-go option runs higher, at 3.09% to 3.69% plus 15 cents (NerdWallet, 2026). Online and keyed-in rates are higher still — always ask for those too.
Does the FTC lawsuit mean my Toast fees will change?
Not automatically. Toast says "nothing about today's news changes our customer service, pricing, or support" (Nation's Restaurant News, 2026). The case is ongoing and could take years. If you are a current Toast customer, review your statement line by line and ask about any add-ons or fees you don't recognize.
Which POS is best for a small full-service restaurant?
Toast offers the deepest all-in-one tools for full-service, but with the longest lock-in. Square's paid Plus and Premium tiers handle many full-service needs with no contract. For a small full-service spot that values flexibility, start with Square; for heavy volume and tight kitchen integration, price out Toast — and read every clause.
What's the single biggest mistake owners make choosing a POS?
Comparing the monthly software fee instead of the all-in cost. The processing rate on every sale, the hardware bill, and the multi-year contract usually dwarf the software fee. Judge on total cost and exit terms, not the headline price — that is the whole point of the FTC's case against Toast's "$0" claims.


